I used to think "startup red flags" were subtle. Like, you had to squint. Maybe read between the lines.
Nope. Most of them drive up in a parade float with a siren on top.
This is part of my Flashes & Failures series, where I write down the stuff you don't see in the glossy founder photos. The grift is real. Sometimes it's dumb. Sometimes it's charismatic. Sometimes it's wearing a Patagonia vest and asking you to "move fast."
Red Flag #1: The culture tells on itself immediately
My first real tech job was a web hosting company in the dot-com era. Day one, the CEO hits me with:
"Always hire a secretary with big boobs."
That's not a joke. That's the entire forecast.
Technically, the job was fun. I was patching Java software on WindowsNT boxes, watching over RAID5 arrays full of SCSI drives. Real "if this dies, everyone screams" infrastructure.
Then I started noticing something in the DNS zone files. A lot of domains had "xxx" and "nude" in them. At first I figured it was random internet grossness. Then the CEO explained it like he was describing payroll:
Adult entertainment pays the bills. It's honestly the only market that makes us any money.
His wife knew. Everyone knew. I was hosting my own little side projects on their servers (early version of what became sethserver), and the CEO would "check out my website." Which I found weird, but I also liked getting paid on time. I was young. I was naturally curious. I was definitely the hero of my own story.
The dot-com bubble popped and the company died. The lesson wasn't "adult is bad." The lesson was: do basic due diligence on culture and clientele before you tie your rent money to it.
Red Flag #2: "Optimize the algorithm" can mean "cheat"
Later I worked on a sports betting startup. The pitch was standard: build a system, tune the model, improve retention. Normal nerd stuff.
Then the founder and an advisor started talking about "optimizing" the algorithm so the house would win more. They didn't call it rigging. They called it "enhancing user experience" and "standard practice."
If you've ever heard someone describe fraud like it's a UX improvement, that's your sign to leave.
I implemented the changes anyway. I didn't feel good about it, but I didn't quit either. I should have.
Users noticed immediately. Complaints rolled in: "You're cheating." Reviews went from positive to scorched earth. Usage dropped. The whole thing became non-viable because, shockingly, people don't like being robbed by math.
The lesson: if your gut says "illegal," trust it. Don't wait for the support inbox to prove you right.
Red Flag #3: Sales can be the grift engine (and leadership may not care)
I also worked at a SaaS marketing automation company selling tools to SMBs. Support was drowning. Customers were angry. Churn was high. The usual "we promised the moon and shipped a flashlight" situation.
So I did what engineers do. I pulled data.
One sales rep had a churn rate that was basically a signature. Clients would sign, onboard, and churn in 1โ2 months. Conveniently, right after the rep collected commissions.
This wasn't "bad fit." This was vaporware sales. Promising features that didn't exist. Promising results the product couldn't deliver.
I walked the evidence to senior leadership. I arrogantly expected swift action. Like: protect customers, fix the process, stop lighting the brand on fire.
Leadership didn't care. Sales KPIs looked good. Investors were happy. The rep stayed. I got laid off later for "financial reasons." The head of support too.
That stuck with me.
A quick checklist I wish I used sooner
If you're joining a startup (or staying at one), ask yourself:
- Who pays the bills? If the real business model is hidden, ask why.
- What happens when you raise a problem? Watch for indifference, not just hostility.
- Does "growth" depend on deception? If yes, you're the fall guy with a laptop.
- Are they selling what exists, or what they hope exists? Hope is not a product.
I've worked with CEOs who wanted out of corporate life more than they wanted to build anything real. I've watched "investment" money show up from bored rich guys who just wanted a story. I've watched teams worship a cult-of-personality leader while the ship was clearly on fire. None of that ends well for the people doing the actual work.
No job is worth trading away your integrity. Also, worthless stock doesn't pay bills. I checked.
Next post I'll talk about hype: how to tell the difference between substance and spin before you waste a year building someone else's press release.
-Sethers